Latest Blog

Keep an eye on equity risk premiums- The New Indian Express

That will then transmit into local equity and bond markets as well. I would argue a little bit that we are not fully decoupled and that there will be transmissions to the Indian economy also. Dison, Will and Rattan, Alex , “An improved model for understanding equity prices,” Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, Bank of England, vol. While fertilizer stocks were a hot topic in 2022 given strong demand and business outlook for the sector, some smallcap and midcap stocks turned multibagger despite market uncertainty. One direct fallout of this would be on foreign portfolio allocation to India and thus foreign inflows.

equity risk premium india

Get live Share Market updates and latest India News and business news on Financial Express. Govt cuts windfall tax on crude; here’s how oil stocks reacted Shares of ONGC, HPCL, and IOC rose up to 1%, while Adani Total Gas, Reliance Industries, and BPCL fell up to 1% on the BSE. Zomato’s ₹4,447 cr acquisition of quick commerce startup Blinkit raises questions about whether this growth is coming at a reasonable cost, says NYU professor. Pay on Delivery (Cash/Card) payment method includes Cash on Delivery as well as Debit card / Credit card / Net banking payments at your doorstep. Our payment security system encrypts your information during transmission.

Dow Futures Fall 30 Pts; Caution Ahead of Fed Announcement

A few others find India’s payouts to be low and hence take the US ERP and add a country risk to arrive at India’s premium. Now that you’ve seen one strategists’ view on the markets, see what everybody thinks. In the S&P 500, utility stocks have gone from laggards in 2013 to leaders in 2014. Interest rate cuts, not increases, precipitated the 2008 bear market.

However, this uptrend is driven largely by a combination of ERP and interest rates, with earnings expectations contributing to a lesser extent. Low interest rate environment attributable to low inflation prevailed alongside compression of risk premium. ERP touched a low of 3.7 per cent during this period and remained lower than the long-term average in the previous years.

The analysis of equity prices and understanding of the drivers of change in equity prices assumes significance as it interacts with monetary policy and could have different implications for policy actions. To further illustrate the point, at the peak of the market in January 2008, Sensex was trading at 24.6 times one year forward earning thus providing an earnings yield of 4% compared to bond yield of 7.74%. But as the market started to weigh the global risks, equity started becoming cheap thus the Sensex earnings yield rose to 8% in March 2009 far higher than the bond yield of 7.1% in that period. Though some have suggested that price dropping to my value is vindication of my valuation, I am not part of that group for three reasons.

First, it seems skewed to celebrate only your successes and not your failures, and it behooves me to let you know that I also valued Paytm at close to Rs 2,000 per share, and the stock is currently trading at Rs 713. Finally, the company and the market have changed in the year since I last valued it, and to make a fair judgment today, the company will have to be revalued. Economists and analysts calculate the equity risk premium using the various method. The technique considers the future profitability of businesses and the potential dividend. The actual process to compute involves a maze of mathematical equations.

equity risk premium india

ERP serves as a key input in determining cost of equity and thus warrants the need for monitoring. While the central bank’s action directly influences part of this cost by affecting the cost of debt, ERP is indirectly altered based on ability of monetary policy to influence risk taking behaviour of investors. From the financial stability point of view, a significantly lower ERP than what is implied by economic factors may lead to sharp and sudden drop in asset prices in any adverse event. It is a lot more complex to understand equity risk premium or ERP for short when it comes to equity.

This is because, unlike a bond, equity does not have any certainty in cash flows over a definite period. Neither your dividends nor the returns are guaranteed over any fixed period. You cannot do a simple cash flow and IRR to know your yield, like you would with debt, unless you make your own estimates. The DDM model enables the ascertainment of factors behind changing cost of equity. During the global financial crisis of 2008, the sharp spike in ERP translated into higher cost of equity/required return on equity even as risk-free rates were declining . The subsequent policy actions in the form of monetary and fiscal stimulus aided in lowering of risk premia and the cost of equity.

ETMarkets Smart Talk: Indian market vulnerable as valuations at meaningful premium to global markets, warns Taher Badshah

In equity, the risk premium is the difference between your ‘expected return on an instrument’ and the risk-free rate . The risk premium shows the required returns, expected returns, and historical returns. In the short term, the demand-supply equation is determined by foreign investors , retail investors, and fresh issuances of companies. Abhay Doshi, co-founder of UnlistedArena said there are multiple factors which are supporting the prices amid muted sentiments in the secondary markets.

He added that since the Second World War, the nominal US GDP growth has been 5% while inflation has been at 2%. “And so, when the ten-year bond yield got above 5%, that’s when you really started to see stocks struggle,” he said. Based on the same theory, only when 10-year yields cross the 3.5% mark, Nelson believes markets would start to struggle. In effect, your expected return on equities was a sum of the risk-free rate and a risk premium you have attached to compensate for the risk of losing your money in equity. The chart below shows the TIPS yield curve—basically the inflation-adjusted rates of return you can currently capture on Treasuries.

The real equity returns vary with the operational performance of businesses that are underlying. The past rates of returns have varied as the economy gets old and goes through cycles, but the traditional knowledge has typically calculated the long-term potential of around 8% annually. Treasuries have generally had comparatively lower yields due to the result of this imagined dependence. The returns on the equity markets are on the basis of the expected returns on a proper benchmark index like the Standard and Poor 500 index.

To see why, start with what the brokerage HDFC Securities is calling the “changing contours of monetary transmission” in India. In March 2020, less than 10% of floating-rate rupee loans were priced off an external benchmark such as the RBI’s repurchase rate. Taking advantage of rising interest rates, lenders have frequently reset loan prices. PEG ratio can prove handy in selecting good stocks as it refines the valuations revealed by standard PE metric by including the estimated earnings growth. This is to inform that, many instances were reported by general public where fraudsters are cheating general public by misusing our brand name Motilal Oswal. The fraudsters are luring the general public to transfer them money by falsely committing attractive brokerage / investment schemes of share market and/or Mutual Funds and/or personal loan facilities.

Features of risk premium in debt

The other important data point that investor can gauge the increase in risk is narrowing of the spread between the bond yield and earnings yield of Nifty. In August 2018 at the peak of the market, this difference was 3.3% , which has narrowed to 2.4%. In 2022, though, the company’s stock rediscovered the laws of gravity, and news stories that would have elicited positive responses in 2021 are having the opposite effect.

Lagged values of both IIP and GDP are included in regression to gauge the predictive power of ERP over and above the past values of independent variables . Lagged terms are identified based on improvement to the overall fit of the model. Ahead of the result of the US Fed’s policy meeting later today, investors traded… An investment of Rs 1 lakh in the shares of RMC Switchgears Ltd one year ago would have turned to Rs11.93 lakh today.

If you call the volatility that is brought about by the change in interest rate cycles as a risk, then you earn a premium for that risk too. But this risk has a lot of external factors involved –inflation, fiscal deficit, GDP growth, currency movements and so on. And it rewards or depreciates an instrument based on the residual maturity. We prefer to call this ‘volatility’ as this risk diminishes with time, as rates move up and down in cycles. But the risk premium coming from default risk can be very real and may not fade away with time. So, it is possible for you to calculate the returns from the bond .

  • “There is a bit of a speculative element also which has led to some froth getting accumulated,” Vinit Sambre, head of equities and fund manager at DSP Mutual Fund, told ETNow in a recent interview.
  • But here again, to do this cash flow, you first need to estimate earnings.
  • Since its listing, Happiest Minds has given superlative returns (nearly 172% as of 1st August 2022).

The growth story of Indian stock markets can be understood from the graph in Figure 1. The Foreign Institutional Investor inflows had tripled in the last eight years and reached 92,000 cr in the month of November 2014. Similarly, Domestic Institutional Investor participation has also tripled and reached a maximum investment of 35,000 cr in the month equity risk premium india of September 2014. It’s not just P/E or P/BV but ERP too, that can tell you whether stocks are overpriced or undervalued. Post market crashes like 2008 or even March 2020, the ERP, according to the RBI paper went up . That means when risk aversion is high, investors seek depressed prices to invest in the same asset now, for it to deliver.

This phase is marked by the global financial crisis, which roiled financial markets across the globe. During this period, the BSE Sensex declined around 60 per cent in a short span of 15 months. According to the DDM decomposition, earnings expectations and equity risk premium contributed to the fall in equity market. Earnings expectations corrected sharply as economic outlook deteriorated, and equity risk premium spiked owing to increased perception of risk and uncertainty. However, the impact of accommodative monetary policy stance is reflected in the positive contribution of interest rate to the movement in equity prices. Central banks also monitor equity prices in pursuit of their objective of maintaining financial stability, which is a prerequisite for price and economic stability.

ETMarkets Fund Manager Talk: Rupee depreciation “single most” key risk for Indian equities: Aditya Sood, InCred AMC

She writes on personal finance including investments, regulations and data stories. Before joining Mint in December 2021, Satya worked as research analyst and also a personal finance writer at The Hindu BusinessLine. On July 21, 2021, I valued Zomato just ahead of its initial public offering at about Rs 41 per share. The market clearly had a very different view, as the stock premiered at Rs 74 per share and soared into the stratosphere, peaking at Rs 169 per share in late 2021.

If the above is still difficult, look at the more quantifiable bond market. If stock markets are in top gear but bond market credit risk premium is going up, it may be a sign of economic stress. Be prepared to tone down your return expectation on equity as well.

The decoupling has resulted in concerns over valuations of the Indian stock market being too high to be healthy. Nifty50’s one-year and two-year forward PE multiples are the highest among emerging market economies. Happiest Minds is a digital transformation IT consulting & services company focusing on big data, analytics, cloud, mobility & security.

Nifty50’s one-year and two-year forward PE multiples are the highest among emerging market economies.

If you are tempted to attribute the price performance to good news from the company, its earnings reports continued to report escalating losses and one of its co-founders quit in September 2021. When you invest, you expect a return at least in line with the risk premium you pay to buy an asset. Equity risk premium is the excess return you pay between holding the risk-free return bond and the risky equity investment. We typically assign a lower risk premium to debt investments than to equity. A debt instrument is a promise to repay you within a fixed period with a fixed amount.

Accuracy of the data as well as subjectivity in the calculation methodology makes it difficult for investors to really compute these metrics, said Oswal. Also, it is a dynamic metric with estimates varying wildly depending on the time frame and method of calculation. Since equity risk premium would also depend upon qualitative criteria, there are chances that two investors could arrive at non-identical results, added Sameer Kaul – MD & CEO, TrustPlutus Wealth. Mukherjee said that they choose to use Aswath Damodaran’s risk premium computation, which is sufficient for the risk premium calculation. “Other sites, like, project asset class predicted risk/return, which retail investors may easily access to gain a helicopter view,” he added. Since 2016, the BSE Sensex gained over 80 per cent touching a lifetime high of on January 14, 2020.

Write a comment